BLACK FRIDAY · UP TO 60% OFF ENDS NOV 30
Man wearing a pale blue performance dress shirt, showing a close fit through the chest and waist

Slim Fit vs Athletic Fit Dress Shirts: Which Should You Get?

Slim Fit vs Athletic Fit Dress Shirts: Which Should You Get?

A slim fit dress shirt tapers close to the body through the chest and waist, while an athletic fit keeps the waist trim but adds room in the chest, shoulders and arms. Choose slim if you're lean and shirts usually fit your chest fine. Choose athletic if shirts that fit your chest and shoulders hang loose at the waist, or if the buttons pull when you reach forward.

The labels vary by brand, so the real answer is in the measurements. Here's how to tell which one you need, using &Collar's size chart as a worked example.

What's the actual difference between slim and athletic fit?

It's the gap between chest and waist. A slim fit is cut for a fairly straight torso: modest chest, waist not much smaller. An athletic fit is cut for a "V": a bigger chest and shoulders relative to the waist, and more room in the upper arms.

Compare a medium in each &Collar fit (shirt measurements in inches, from our size guide):

Medium Collar Chest Waist Sleeve
Slim 16 40 30–32 33.5
Athletic 16.5 45 32–34 33.5

Same sleeve, but the athletic medium gives five more inches through the chest and only a couple more at the waist. That's the whole idea: room where muscle is, no tent where it isn't.

How do I know if I need athletic fit?

You probably want athletic if two or more of these sound familiar:

  • Buttons pull or gap across your chest, even though the collar fits.
  • Sleeves feel tight around your biceps or when you bend your elbow.
  • You size up to fit your shoulders, and the waist balloons out over your belt.
  • You lift, swim, play a sport, or just have a naturally broad frame.
  • Your shoulder seams sit inside your shoulder bone instead of on the edge.

If none of those apply and regular shirts feel boxy on you, slim is your fit. More fit checks in How Should a Dress Shirt Fit?

Is athletic fit the same as regular or classic fit?

Not quite. A traditional classic or regular fit is roomy everywhere, including the waist, so it can blouse out above your belt. An athletic fit adds room up top but stays tapered at the waist. That said, some brands use the words loosely; on some &Collar polos, quarter zips and flannels, for example, the roomier fit is labeled "Classic (Athletic)." Always compare the chest and waist numbers rather than trusting the name.

Is slim fit the same as skinny or extra slim?

No. Extra slim or "skinny" fits cut even closer, with little ease anywhere, and suit very lean builds. A slim fit is fitted without clinging. If you can see the outline of your undershirt or the buttons strain when you sit, it's too tight, whatever the label says.

What sizes do slim and athletic fit come in?

At &Collar, Slim runs XS–XL and Athletic runs S–3XL, with the white long sleeve and white short sleeve performance shirts going up to 5XL in Athletic. Tall versions add length in the body and sleeves; see the tall white dress shirt.

Size Slim chest Athletic chest
S 39" 42"
M 40" 45"
L 41.75" 50"
XL 43.25" 53"
2XL – 57"
3XL – 61"

These are shirt measurements, not body measurements; a shirt needs a few inches of ease over your body to move. If you're between sizes, our dress shirt sizes guide walks through how to choose.

Does stretch fabric change which fit I need?

A little. A rigid cotton shirt has no give, so a muscular guy often has to size up and accept a baggy waist. A performance shirt with real four-way stretch, like an &Collar performance dress shirt, gives when you reach, sit or lift your arms, so you can wear a closer cut without pulling at the buttons. It doesn't replace the right fit, though: if your chest is far bigger than your waist, athletic will still look cleaner.

Slim vs athletic: quick decision table

If you… Choose
Are lean, shirts often look boxy Slim
Have broad shoulders and a trim waist Athletic
Have big arms; sleeves feel tight Athletic
Need a 2XL or 3XL Athletic
Wear it tucked with a tie and want minimal fabric at the belt Slim, if the chest fits
Are heavier through the middle Athletic (more room overall), and check the waist measurement

For bigger builds specifically, read Dress Shirts for Big and Athletic Guys.

Frequently asked questions

Should I size up in slim fit or switch to athletic?

Switch to athletic. Sizing up in slim adds length and sleeve along with chest, so you end up with a long, loose shirt. Athletic adds chest and arm room while keeping the length and waist in proportion.

Can a skinny guy wear athletic fit?

He can, but it will usually look roomy through the chest and arms. Lean builds tend to look sharpest in slim.

Does athletic fit look baggy tucked in?

It shouldn't, if the waist measurement matches you. Athletic fits are tapered; the extra room is in the chest and shoulders, not at the belt.

Do slim fit shirts shrink?

Cotton shirts can shrink a little in a hot dryer. &Collar's polyester-and-spandex performance shirts are made not to shrink; wash cold and hang dry or tumble dry low.

What fit is best for a dress shirt under a suit?

Whichever one follows your body without pulling. Extra fabric bunches under a jacket, so a slim or athletic cut usually works better than a classic fit under a suit.